Article: Comedogenic Ingredients List: What the 0 to 5 Ratings Mean
Comedogenic Ingredients List: What the 0 to 5 Ratings Mean
Key takeaways
- The comedogenic scale grades ingredients from 0 to 5 by how much they plug follicles in a rabbit-ear test.
- Those tests used ingredients diluted to about 10%, so a rating is not the same as how a finished product behaves.
- Human evidence is mixed. Small trials of finished products found no clogging, while one 2025 survey linked cleansers containing listed comedogenic ingredients to acne.
- No study validates the 0 to 5 numbers as a predictor for a finished product on your skin.
- "Non-comedogenic" is not a regulated term in Australia. It is a claim the brand has to be able to support.
- Use the number as a rough guide, then judge the whole formula and how your own skin responds.
The comedogenic scale rates ingredients from 0 to 5 by how likely they are to block pores, with 0 meaning no plugging and 5 meaning severe plugging. It is a useful starting point and a poor final answer. Below is where the numbers came from, what the studies actually show, a list of the highest-graded ingredients, and the ratings for the ingredients we use.
What does non-comedogenic mean?
A comedone is a clogged pore. Non-comedogenic is a term brands use for products formulated to avoid blocking pores. It is not a regulated term in Australia and there is no single test every product must pass. The Australian Consumer Law still applies, so a brand needs reasonable grounds for the claim and the overall impression must not mislead (see the ACCC guidance in the sources).
It also does not mean "will not cause acne". Comedones, acne, irritation, allergy and rough texture are different things, and a product can affect one without the others. If you are working through breakouts, our guide to clogged pores covers the causes.
Where the 0 to 5 scale comes from
Most charts online trace back to the rabbit-ear model. Fulton (1989) applied ingredients to the inner ear of rabbits once a day, five days a week, for two weeks, then graded follicle plugging from 0 to 5. Unless stated otherwise, ingredients were mixed in propylene glycol at a 9 to 1 dilution, which is about 10%. So a rating describes an ingredient at roughly 10% in a rabbit model, not the neat ingredient and not a finished product.
What the studies show
There is real research behind comedogenicity, but it is mostly rabbit work and small human studies. Here is what the main papers found.
| Study | Model | What it found |
|---|---|---|
| Kligman and Mills, 1972 | Rabbit ear | Introduced the idea of "acne cosmetica". Reported that as many as half of commercial cosmetics were comedogenic in the rabbit ear. |
| Mills and Kligman, 1982 | Human upper back, follicular biopsy | Substances that were moderately to strongly comedogenic in the rabbit ear could induce comedones in people. The rabbit is more sensitive. Substances weakly comedogenic in the rabbit are probably safe for human use, with the possible exception of acne-prone people. |
| Fulton, 1989 | Rabbit ear | The ingredient tables most charts use. It notes that materials non-comedogenic in the rabbit appear non-comedogenic in the human model, whether highly comedogenic ones always are in people remains uncertain, and the base an ingredient is mixed into can raise or lower its grade. |
| Petrolatum study, 1996 | Human, about 20 people with acne, 8 weeks | Petrolatum products that scored as comedogenic in the rabbit ear showed no comedogenic effect in people, and inflamed pimples decreased. The author concluded that greasiness does not equal comedogenicity. |
| Draelos and DiNardo, 2006 | Human finished products, 6 people, 4 weeks | Finished products using comedogenic ingredients were not necessarily comedogenic. |
| Safety trial, Contemporary Clinical Trials Communications, 2021 | Double-blind randomised trial, 12 men analysed, 4 weeks, occluded upper-back patches | Four vitamin E creams containing ingredients such as lanolin, avocado oil and sunflower oil were judged non-comedogenic, while the positive control (octyl palmitate) increased microcomedones by about 365%. Small, male-only and occluded, which the authors note does not reflect normal use. |
| Choi and colleagues, 2025 | Case-control survey, 151 women (81 with facial acne, 70 without) | Women with acne were more likely to use facial cleansers with a listed comedogenic ingredient among their top 10 ingredients (adjusted odds ratio 2.49). The moisturiser result was unclear because the paper's text and table disagree. Toners and serums showed no link. It shows an association, not cause, and the ingredient list was built from rabbit-ear data. |
What this adds up to:
- A low rabbit-ear grade has tended to hold up in people. A high grade has not reliably predicted what finished products do on human skin.
- One 2025 survey suggests lists of comedogenic ingredients may carry some real signal, at least for cleansers, but it cannot show that the ingredients caused the acne.
- The human studies are small and selective. They range from 6 to about 150 people, and the back-patch method used occlusion on the upper back, which is not how people use products on their faces.
- No study validates the 0 to 5 numbers as a predictor of how a finished product will behave on your face. That is why we use the scale as a screen, not as proof.
Why a rating is only a starting point
- The model is sensitive. A rabbit ear reacts more readily than human skin, and it is uncertain whether highly rated ingredients are always comedogenic in people.
- Concentration and vehicle matter. The same ingredient can score differently at a different strength or in a different base.
- Finished products behave differently. See the 2006 and 2021 studies above. Both were small, so treat them as a caution about the scale rather than proof either way.
- Sources disagree. Charts online differ from each other and from Fulton, and many values come from secondary lists. Shea butter appears at 2 to 4 and sweet almond oil at 2 to 3 for that reason.
Comedogenic ingredients list: Fulton grades 3 to 5
These are the ingredients Fulton graded 3, 4 or 5 for comedogenicity. We transcribed them from the published paper. Rows we could not read clearly on the scanned page are left out, so this is not every ingredient in the study.
Grade 5: isopropyl isostearate, isopropyl myristate, myristyl myristate, laureth-4, oleth-3.
Grade 4: acetylated lanolin alcohol, PEG 16 lanolin, cetyl acetate, ethylhexyl palmitate, isopropyl linolate, isopropyl palmitate, isostearyl isostearate, myristyl lactate, stearyl heptanoate, isocetyl alcohol, oleyl alcohol, glyceryl-3-diisostearate, polyglyceryl-3-diisostearate, steareth-10, lauric acid, cocoa butter, coconut butter.
Grade 3: myristic acid, butyl stearate, decyl oleate, dioctyl malate, dioctyl succinate, isostearyl neopentanoate, sorbitan oleate, wheat germ glyceride, PEG 200 dilaurate, laureth-23, oleth-5, PPG 2 myristyl propionate, PPG 10 cetyl ether, glyceryl stearate SE, hydrogenated vegetable oil, sulfated jojoba oil.
A high grade is a reason to look closer, not a reason to throw a product out. Where an ingredient sits in the list and how much is used both matter.
More ingredients commonly graded 2 or higher
Other published charts, which draw on Fulton and later sources, add more ingredients, including many oils. We have not been able to check these against the original paper, and charts differ from each other, so treat them as approximate.
| Ingredient | Commonly listed range |
|---|---|
| Coconut oil (Cocos nucifera) | 4 |
| Soybean oil | 3 |
| Cottonseed oil | 3 |
| Evening primrose oil | 3 |
| Shark liver oil | 3 |
| Mink oil | 2 to 3 |
| Grapeseed oil | 2 to 3 |
| Peanut oil | 2 |
| Peach kernel oil | 2 |
| Sandalwood seed oil | 2 |
| Sweet almond oil | 2 to 3 |
| Lanolin acid | 4 |
| Xylene | 4 |
| Propylene glycol isostearate | 3 to 4 |
| TEA-stearate | 3 |
| Dicapryl succinate, dicapryl maleate, isopropyl lanolate | 3 |
| Myristyl alcohol, arachidic acid, triethanolamine, diethylhexyl succinate, propylene glycol dipelargonate | 2 |
| Colour pigments such as CI 12085, CI 26100 and CI 73360 | 3 |
| Colour pigments such as CI 14700, CI 16035, CI 45380 and CI 45410 | 2 |
Comedogenic ratings for the ingredients we use
Ratings marked "commonly listed" come from secondary compilations, not from Fulton, so read them as approximate.
| Ingredient we use | Commonly listed range | What to know |
|---|---|---|
| Hemp seed oil | 0 | Listed at 0 in most charts. Not tested by Fulton. In our Antioxidant Moisturiser and Vitamin C Elixir. |
| Argan oil | 0 | Not tested by Fulton. In our Vitamin C Elixir. |
| Squalane | 0 to 1 | Fulton's oil table appears to include squalane, but the scan was too garbled to read the grade with confidence. In our Vitamin C Elixir. |
| Camellia seed oil | 0 to 1 | Charts vary. Not tested by Fulton. In our Vitamin C Elixir. |
| Rosehip oil | 1 | Not tested by Fulton. In our Vitamin C Elixir. |
| Jojoba oil | 0 to 2 | Fulton recorded 0 to 2. Many charts show 2. In our Vitamin C Elixir. |
| Sweet almond oil | 2 to 3 | Charts disagree: many list 2, some list 3. Fulton's oil table includes almond oil, but the scan was too garbled to read its grade with confidence. In our Antioxidant Moisturiser and Vitamin C Elixir. |
| Sunflower oil | 0 to 2 | Fulton noted sunflower and safflower tend to be less comedogenic. Charts vary. In our Vitamin C Elixir. |
| Caprylic/capric triglyceride | 2 | Light ester. Charts vary slightly. Fulton graded a similar ingredient, glyceryl tricaprylo/caprate, at 1. In our Vitamin C Elixir. |
| Mango butter | 2 | Not tested by Fulton. In our Antioxidant Moisturiser. |
| Shea butter | 2 to 4 | Sources disagree and Fulton did not test it. The widest range of any ingredient we use. In our Antioxidant Moisturiser and Retinol & Peptide Night Repair Cream. |
| Cetearyl alcohol (emulsifier) | 2 | Graded 2 by Fulton, so some of our creams contain a 2 alongside the oils. |
Fulton grades for other common ingredients
| Ingredient | Fulton grade (0 to 5) | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Cetyl alcohol | 2 | A fatty alcohol, not a drying one |
| Stearyl alcohol | 2 | |
| Cetearyl alcohol | 2 | Very common in creams |
| Ceteareth-20 | 2 | Emulsifier |
| Stearic acid | 2 to 3 | Scan unclear on the exact range |
| Palmitic acid | 2 | |
| Capric acid | 2 | |
| Ascorbyl palmitate | 2 | In our Vitamin C Elixir |
| Glyceryl stearate (non-self-emulsifying) | 1 | The self-emulsifying version is graded 3 |
| Butylene glycol | 1 | |
| Caprylic acid | 1 | |
| Candelilla wax | 1 | |
| Kaolin | 0 | Clay. Talc was graded 1. |
| Jojoba oil | 0 to 2 | Result varied between samples |
| Anhydrous lanolin | 0 to 1 | |
| Propylene glycol | 0 | |
| Glycerin | 0 | Humectant, not an oil |
| Polysorbate 20 and 80 | 0 | |
| Bentonite | 0 |
Petrolatum and mineral oil are cited differently by different sources, and the 1996 study above found petrolatum was not comedogenic in people. Dimethicone is covered in our dimethicone guide, and coconut oil in our coconut oil guide.
These are ratings of ingredients, not of any product. A cream with a 2-rated emulsifier can still suit someone who clogs easily, and a product made only of 0-rated ingredients can still bother someone else.
How we choose ingredients at Dope Skin Co
Our formulator aims for oils rated 2 or below on the commonly cited scale, and reviews each recipe as a whole. This is a formulation judgement, not an independent test result, and 2 is not a scientific cut-off. Some of our products include ingredients at or above the upper edge of that aim, such as shea butter, sweet almond oil (listed at 2 to 3) and cetearyl alcohol, which is why we show the full table above rather than only the best numbers.
We have not run finished-product comedogenicity studies on our products, and we do not claim any product will suit every skin. Where we say a product is non-comedogenic, that reflects how it is formulated.
- Ingredient research looks at one raw ingredient, usually in a model such as the rabbit ear.
- A formulation assessment is a formulator reviewing the whole recipe. It is expert judgement, not a test.
- A finished-product human study tests the actual product on people. We have not done one.
Where these ingredients show up in our range
- Antioxidant Moisturiser: hemp seed oil, sweet almond oil, mango butter and shea butter.
- Vitamin C Antioxidant Elixir with CoQ10: a blend of light plant oils with squalane.
- Botanical Antioxidant Serum: an oil-free gel, if you want to skip oils altogether.
- Retinol & Peptide Night Repair Cream: a richer night cream, so read its full ingredient list against the tables above.
- Antioxidant Gel Cleanser and the 6-Step Clear Skin Kit: for a full routine aimed at congestion.
How to choose if your pores clog easily
- Treat 0 to 2 as a lower-risk guide, not a guarantee.
- Read the whole ingredient list, including your cleanser. Esters, fatty acids, fatty alcohols and emulsifiers can score higher than the oils.
- Introduce one new product at a time and give it a few weeks.
- Use a patch test for irritation and allergy. It does not test for comedogenicity.
- If a product seems to clog you, stop it, keep the rest of your routine steady, and see a GP or dermatologist if breakouts persist.
Not sure where to start? Our skincare quiz matches products to your skin.
Frequently asked questions
Is there a scientific study behind comedogenic ratings? Yes. The ratings come from rabbit-ear studies, and small human studies have tested some of the same substances. None shows that a rating reliably predicts what a finished product will do on your skin.
Is hemp seed oil comedogenic? It is commonly listed at 0, among the lowest on the scale, though Fulton did not test it. That describes the raw oil, not a finished product.
Is jojoba oil non-comedogenic? Fulton recorded 0 to 2 depending on the sample, and many charts show 2. It sits in the low range but is not a guaranteed 0.
Is shea butter comedogenic? Sources disagree, with a commonly listed range of 2 to 4, and it was not graded by Fulton.
Is sweet almond oil comedogenic? Charts disagree. Many list it at 2 and some at 3.
Is coconut oil comedogenic? It is commonly listed at 4, which is high on the scale, though responses vary between people. Fulton graded coconut butter at 4.
Does non-comedogenic mean it will not cause acne? No. It describes how a product is formulated, not what it will do on your skin. This article is general information, not medical advice.
Is a patch test the same as a comedogenicity test? No. A patch test looks for irritation or allergy.
Sources
- Kligman AM, Mills OH. Acne cosmetica. Archives of Dermatology 1972;106:843-850.
- Mills OH Jr, Kligman AM. A human model for assessing comedogenic substances. Archives of Dermatology 1982;118:903-905. JAMA Dermatology
- Fulton JE Jr. Comedogenicity and irritancy of commonly used ingredients in skin care products. Journal of the Society of Cosmetic Chemists 1989;40(6):321-333. Read the methods
- Groh DG, Mills OH Jr, Kligman AM. Quantitative assessment of cyanoacrylate follicular biopsies by image analysis. Journal of the Society of Cosmetic Chemists 1992;43:101-112. Read online
- Petrolatum is not comedogenic in rabbits or humans: a critical reappraisal of the rabbit ear assay and the concept of acne cosmetica. Journal of the Society of Cosmetic Chemists 1996;47:41-48. Read online
- Draelos ZD, DiNardo JC. A re-evaluation of the comedogenicity concept. Journal of the American Academy of Dermatology 2006;54(3):507-12. PubMed
- Safety assessment on comedogenicity of dermatological products containing d-alpha tocopheryl acetate in Asian subjects: a double-blind randomized controlled trial. Contemporary Clinical Trials Communications 2021;23:100834. PubMed Central
- Choi K, Liu H, Zhu Y, Jiang Z, Lu S. A case-control study exploring the association between cosmetic use and acne risk. Clinical, Cosmetic and Investigational Dermatology 2025;18:1833-1843. Read online
- Australian Competition and Consumer Commission. False or misleading claims. accc.gov.au


